"Over the past four years, Gen. Cedric Wins, superintendent of Virginia Military Institute, has done a masterful job of advancing the mission of educating citizen soldiers through the rigorous methods unique to VMI while safeguarding the institute from acts of racism that threatened its very existence at the outset of his administration."
- Editorial, The News-Gazette (Lexington, VA), February 26, 2025
To the Members of the Virginia Military Institute Board of Visitors,
We, the undersigned alumni, cadets, faculty, parents and supporters of the Virginia Military Institute, write to express our deep concern and request answers regarding the Board’s recent decision to not renew the contract of Superintendent General Cedric Wins. We understand the importance of the board's role in guiding the Institute, but we feel compelled to seek clarity on the factors and considerations that led to this decision, given the nature of the process in which it was made.
This decision, made in a hastily scheduled, closed-door session with less than four days notice thereby limiting the opportunity for public input, and without transparency or explanation, has sent shockwaves through the VMI community and raises serious concerns about the motives behind this abrupt and unjustifiable action.
General Wins, a decorated VMI graduate and retired U.S. Army general, was appointed at a critical time in VMI’s history and has executed his duties with distinction, integrity, and results. His leadership has been instrumental in executing VMI’s "One Corps, One VMI" strategic plan, which has strengthened the Institute in multiple critical areas:
Preserving VMI’s Core Traditions While Advancing Excellence
Under General Wins, VMI has maintained its rigorous military and academic traditions while modernizing in ways necessary to ensure continued excellence. He has protected the Honor Code, upheld the Rat Line, and preserved VMI’s reputation as a leader in developing military and civilian leaders of character.
Academic Growth & Investment
General Wins spearheaded historic investments in STEM education and faculty development, ensuring that VMI remains competitive with top-tier military and engineering institutions. He has secured funding for academic enhancements that will benefit generations of cadets.
Record-Breaking Fundraising and Financial Stability
Under his leadership, VMI raised over $44 million in donations in a single year an all-time record demonstrating overwhelming support from alumni and donors who believed in his vision for the Institute.
Strong Recruiting & Cadet Success
At a time when military academies and ROTC programs across the country are struggling with recruitment, VMI maintained stable enrollment while improving retention rates. He prioritized leadership training, discipline, and the holistic development of cadets.
Defending VMI’s Reputation
General Wins successfully navigated unfair political attacks and external pressures while steadfastly upholding VMI’s mission. His leadership ensured that VMI continued to produce principled leaders while maintaining high standards in all aspects of cadet life.
Given these accomplishments, the Board’s decision to not renew General Wins' contract is inexplicable and unacceptable. More troubling is the fact that this decision was made with time-limited opportunity for public discussion, little transparency and no subsequent explanation - against the will of thousands of alumni, cadets, faculty, and supporters who have stood behind his leadership.
Therefore, we demand the following from the Board of Visitors:
1. A Full and Immediate Explanation: The VMI community deserves to know why General Wins—who has executed his duties with distinction—was dismissed. What specific concerns or criteria led to this decision?
2. Disclosure of the Decision-Making Process: Who was involved in this decision, what criteria were used, and why was this process conducted in secrecy?
3. A Clear Plan for the Future: What is the Board’s plan moving forward? How do you intend to sustain the positive momentum established under General Wins?
4. Commitment to Transparency: We demand that all major decisions affecting the leadership and direction of VMI be made with proper consultation from alumni, faculty, and stakeholders—not in backroom meetings devoid of accountability.
Our commitment to the Virginia Military Institute is unwavering. As alumni, cadets, parents and stakeholders, we ask for the opportunity to better understand the reasons for this decision and to be part of the ongoing dialogue to shape the future of VMI.
We await your prompt and transparent response to these important concerns.
Sincerely,
Alumni, Cadets, Faculty, Parents and Supporters of the Virginia Military Institute
General Wins strengthened academic performance, bolstered the school's finances, and reversed a 10-year decline in admissions.
Increased state funding by 50% and secured over $321 million to upgrade VMI facilities
Boosted Pell Grant enrollment with a $3.8 grant and maintained budget surpluses when most people expected deficits.
General Wins has enhanced cadet life and upheld tradition with modern excellence.
Under his leadership, VMI was the only senior military college to receive a 5-star ranking from Money Magazine.
Launched the Call to Duty scholarship program - awarding $2.4 million to 172 cadets.
Reinforced VMI's class and regimental systems, including appointing the first female regimental commander in 25 years.
Athletics achieved significant milestones, including the first conference championship in football since 1977.
His record demonstrates his ability to nurture future leaders with the strength and integrity our country desperately needs - it speaks louder than inflammatory buzzwords and racist rhetoric.
The Board's decision was never about the General's performance or tangible progress - it was the result of partisans abandoning VMI's core values of honor, integrity, and excellence.
General Wins' tenure will end because leaders became corrupted by the Spirit of Racist Ideology rather than relying on sound judgement.
The Board is responsible for VMI's future. Short-sighted political games risk destroying the school.
The Board initiated a harmful multi-year cycle of political retaliation and retribution. Its misfeasance endangers VMI, its cadets and the future of our national security.
General Wins remains committed to serving VMI until his tenure ends.
To safeguard VMI, cadets, alumns, faculty and supporters of authentic leadership must commit to valor over ideology and political expediency.
VMI is more than merely another state school. It is entrusted with creating a pipeline of leaders that serve the Commonwealth and the nation with honor, integrity and excellence.
We hope the General Assembly will stop extremists from subverting VMI as a crucible for principled leaders into a training ground for unprincipled fanatics.
VMI superintendent to SCHEV board: 'campuses aren't political footballs'
(Roanoke Times, March 18, 2025)
(Cardinal News, March 12, 2025)
Commentary: the injustice at VMI will reverberate beyond Wins' ouster
(Richmond Times-Dispatch, March 11, 2025)
Democrats want to send a message to VMI but haven't said what it will be
(Cardinal News, March 10, 2025)
VMI alums leading effort to get 'explanation' on ouster of Black superintendent
(Augusta Free Press, March 8, 2025)
VMI leader blames 'bias' and 'ideology' for vote not to extend contract
(Washington Post, March 6, 2025)
'Partison choice': VMI superintendent responds after vote not to extend contract
(Virginia Mercury, March 5, 2025)
VMI board opted out of extending first Black superintendent’s contract
(Associated Press, March 1, 2025)
In 1928, some state leaders wanted to close VMI. The risk of that happening could come back.
(Cardinal News, February 28, 2025)
VMI board declines to extend contract of Superintendent Cedric Wins
(Washington Post, February 28, 2025)
VMI board ousts first Black superintendent in controversial vote
(Virginia Mercury, February 28, 2025)
Amid furor over diversity efforts, VMI board ousts school’s first Black superintendent
(Cardinal News, February 28, 2025)
Power struggle at VMI: Governor, lawmakers clash over Black superintendent’s future
(Virginia Mercury, February 26, 2025)
Venue and Address
201 Smith Hall, Virginia Military Institute
Lexington, VA 24450
No. In Alma Mater's Name is not a fundraising organization, nor do we solicit or accept donations. We invite you to direct your financial support to the VMI Alumni Agencies.
No. We are a non-partisan, non-political, and volunteer-led community committed to advocating for the long-term success of VMI. We invite all individuals to sign the open letter.
We welcome anyone to sign the open letter, whether you attended VMI, graduated from VMI, have a daughter or son attending VMI, or anyone else interested in its wellbeing.
We are not affiliated with VMI in any official capacity, although we represent a diverse collection of alumni, cadets, faculty, parents and other supporters interested in the long-term wellbeing and survival of the Institute.